Playmage Forum

I hadn't realized that there is a path you can choose until reading http://www.playmage.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=220#p1188

So, which gives the better reward anyways?

Well, the girl in red will ask you to either kill a number of a specific monster in a specific area or to kill the wise man.
The demon only asks you to kill to girl.

The drops are about the same. However, I feel like the girl shows up a bit more often than the demon, so you might get more chances for rewards by helping the girl. The trade off is you'd probably be killing the wise man once every 2-3 times he shows up and you'd always have to kill the demon.

I personally chose to help the demon.

The girl may also ask you to beat up the gambler. The rewards are he same so it's just a matter of who shows up more often. The girl does show up more often than the imp for me, but I don't like the chance quest of monster hunting, takes too long. Plus beating up the wise man is a bit of a waste as his rewads for trivia or a simple chat are pretty neat. I go with helping the imp myself, but I guess it's more a matter of taste than anything.