The present guild war rewards, and guild war rewards in general actually, are total pants apart from the top card. Playmage have missed a trick with the dragon queen /king guild wars particularly in that they could have given 2,3,4, and 5 star dragons as all the lower rewards which would have been much more useful to everyone.
The present ones, especially the bottom 2, the 4* doll and 3* octopus are completely useless. Who on earth could ever want those? They are simply rubbish for recycling. Those sort of rewards do not encourage lower players in guilds to even take part. I have several who aren't bothering with it at all. If Playmage at least put something useful for everyone as the lower rewards then those players would think it was worth taking part after all.
I hope the new update addresses this because all those lower rewards aren't even rewards, they're just an insult!