Hi,
I wanted to share my opinion on the star status in guild and also get other people's opinion on the matter.
As it is, the amount of star members is restricted. This means that even if everyone contributes the same gold, is equally active and do about the same contribution to the guild wars, not everyone can get the star.
I have asked over and over for this to change, but sadly it hasn't. This has the potential to create disagreement within guild and makes the guild leader's job a lot harder.
My suggestion has always been to not limit the star amount in guild. The leader who has the final choice, can decide if he wants to promote his members to star, and if he doesn't think a member deserves star status then he won't.
So what do you guys think? Is the star status something not that important that it shouldn't matter? 2% can go a long way to some weaker cards. I personally hope the devs can make a change.